How to deal with employees who don't get along
Short answer: First decide whether this is a personality clash or a conduct problem like harassment, discrimination or threats, because the second kind needs a formal process, not a sit-down chat. For a clash, talk to each person alone, agree on working rules as a group, use the schedule as a short-term tool, and follow up. Gossip and drama often sits underneath this, so look there too.
Start by sorting the problem, not the people
Two baristas who can't stand each other and two employees accused of a threat are not the same problem, even though both show up as "they don't get along." Before you do anything else, ask yourself: is this a clash of styles and personalities, or is it harassment, discrimination, bullying, or a safety issue?
If it's the second kind, stop trying to get the two of them to "work it out" over a coffee. Conduct problems need a documented, formal process: separate written statements, a clear policy you can point to, and if you're not sure, a call to an employment attorney or your state labor office. Mixing a conduct complaint into a casual mediation chat can make things worse for everyone, including you.
Most of what owners mean by "my employees don't get along" is the first kind: two people who rub each other the wrong way, grind on each other's nerves during a rush, or have a style clash that spills onto the floor. That's what the rest of this page covers.
The pattern owners describe most often
- Two counter staff at a cafe who are fine apart but tense the second they're on the same shift.
- Kitchen staff and front-of-house staff sniping at each other over ticket times, every single dinner rush.
- Two retail associates who have quietly agreed to never work the closing shift together.
- A shift that runs smoothly with almost any pairing except one specific combination.
In each case, the owner usually finds out about it from the schedule falling apart, from a customer comment, or from a third coworker finally saying something. By the time you hear it, the rest of the team has usually been managing around it for weeks.
Step by step: handling a personality clash
- Talk to each person alone first. Don't start with a joint meeting. Ask each one, separately, what's going on from their side, and what it looks like on the floor when it flares up.
- Keep it about behavior and impact, not character. "When you two argue about ticket order in front of customers, tables wait longer and the floor notices" lands better than "you two need to grow up."
- Hold a joint conversation with ground rules, not a therapy session. Bring both people together once you've heard each side. Set two or three concrete rules for the shift: who calls tickets, how handoffs happen, what gets said out loud versus saved for later.
- Write the rules down and agree on them out loud. A short list both people nod to beats a vague "let's all get along."
- Use the schedule as a short-term tool, not a permanent fix. Keeping two people apart for a week while things cool down is fine. Permanently rearranging every shift around a feud just trains the rest of the team that conflict gets rewarded with accommodation.
- Follow up on a set date. Check in after a week or two, not just once. Ask each person privately whether the ground rules are holding.
Kitchen versus floor: a specific fix
When the fight is between departments rather than two individuals, like kitchen staff versus servers, a shared pre-shift huddle helps more than any single conversation. Five minutes before doors open, have both sides hear the same specials, the same 86'd items, and the same expected volume, together, in the same room.
Rotating a day in the other role also helps more than most owners expect. A server who runs the pass for one shift, or a line cook who takes orders for an hour, usually comes back with a lot more sympathy for the other side's problems and a lot less certainty that they're the only one working hard.
Seeing the pattern instead of hearing about it after the fact
The hardest part of this problem is usually not the fix, it's finding out which pairings and which people are actually the source of friction before it costs you a shift, a customer, or a resignation. Owners often hear about this secondhand, weeks after the rest of the crew has already adjusted around it.
This is one place where anonymous coworker ratings can help, as one piece of a bigger approach, not the whole fix. Wevree is staff management for teams, from cafes to offices and retail, built on anonymous peer evaluation. The owner picks Topics that matter, and "helps teammates without being asked" is a common one. Each Round, staff rate their coworkers from 1 to 10, alone and anonymously, on their phones, on a schedule the owner sets. A rater who gives a 5 or lower is asked what should improve, so patterns on a specific person or a specific pairing tend to surface over a few Rounds instead of staying hallway gossip. Staff can also send the owner an anonymous report, separate from ratings, about something nobody wants to say out loud, like a lead who plays favorites or a conflict that's gotten uncomfortable.
Wevree is not a mediation tool. It will not sit two employees down, draft ground rules, or tell you who is "right." It does not rank or compare workers against each other, and it will not tell you which employees the rest of the team "wants to work with," because that's not something it shows. What it gives an owner is a steadier, anonymous read on how teammates experience working with each other over time, which can point you toward a conversation you might otherwise only have after someone quits. Nobody sees who gave which score, not coworkers, not managers, not the owner, and scores cannot be edited or deleted by anyone, including the owner. Built for teams of 4 or more staff, with each result needing at least 3 coworker ratings.
Owners at places like Belle Journee and Cast Iron use Wevree alongside the usual day-to-day management, not instead of it. You can try it for 30 days.
Frequently asked questions
How do I handle two employees who can't stand each other?
Talk to each privately about the behavior and its effect on the shift, then bring them together for a short conversation that ends with a few concrete ground rules, such as who calls tickets or how handoffs happen. Follow up in a week or two rather than assuming one talk fixed it.
My kitchen and floor staff snipe at each other every shift. What do I do?
Add a short shared pre-shift huddle so both sides hear the same information at the same time, and have people rotate into the other role for a shift occasionally so each side understands the other's pressure points.
Two of my retail associates refuse to work the same shift. Should I just keep them apart?
Separating them short-term while you work the problem is reasonable, but a permanent split just trains the rest of the team that conflict gets rewarded. Use the time to find out what's actually going on and set ground rules before you go back to a normal schedule.
How do I know if this is personality conflict or something more serious?
If it involves harassment, discrimination, threats, or anything that could violate your policies or local law, treat it as a conduct issue with a formal, documented process, not a casual mediation chat. When in doubt, check your written policy or talk to an employment attorney.
Is there a way to see how restaurant coworkers actually rate working with each other?
Anonymous coworker ratings on a Topic like helping teammates can show a pattern over several Rounds without turning it into a ranking or a popularity contest. Wevree works this way, though it's one input among several, not a substitute for talking to your team.
Is there a tool that shows which employees the team wants to work with?
No, and that's not something Wevree does. It does not rank or compare workers against each other or produce a leaderboard; it shows the owner each person's anonymous ratings over time so patterns are visible without turning into a popularity contest.
Can a scheduling app fix employees who don't get along?
A scheduling app can keep two people apart for a while, but it won't fix the underlying friction. That takes a direct conversation, clear ground rules, and follow-up.
Related pages
- Gossip and drama on a small team
- When employees fight, how do I know who's right?
- How to build a good team at a small restaurant
- Signs of a toxic workplace and how to fix it
- Manager favoritism on a small team
- How to get honest anonymous feedback from restaurant staff
- Peer review questions for employees
- Wevree for restaurants and cafes
Sources
Wevree facts were checked against the latest Wevree app code on November 18, 2026. The management advice on this page is general practice, not a study result.